PCBgogo

Electronic Project Engineer's Best Partner!
****
Any downside to double sided ground plane?
577 1 May 27.2019, 16:33:52

Whenever I draw up even a relatively simple board I always pour a ground plane on both sides. This makes things easy from the point of view that I don't have to be overly concerned about how to get a ground track to everywhere it has to go. Also makes for great low impedance earth run. I am very aware of the significance of ground loops and coupling through shared earth runs. Thirdly, it doesn't consume so much etchant because only relatively little copper has to be removed. Why waste it for no good reason, even if someone else is doing the board manufacture? 
Anyway, is there a downside to having a ground plane if it is not absolutely necessary? Any stuff with a decent bit of voltage I raise above the board, and am aware of the extra heat needed to solder & unsolder some connections.

  • Comments(1)
Upload a photo:You can only upload 1 files in total. Each file cannot exceed 2MB.Supports JPG, JPEG, GIF, PNG, BMP
Browse
Submit
header
A****min

May 29.2019, 09:07:51

Nope*!
*Consider what you are doing.  If the planes are well stitched, and surround all traces pretty well, then all the traces are nice transmission lines, specifically coplanar waveguide construction.  At typical dimensions, this lands in the 70-100 ohm range, which is quite reasonable for most CMOS digital stuff.
You also get isolation between traces, at least if there's enough clearance between traces that ground pours inbetween them (for at least a trace width, and via-stitched in at least two places).  If not (running traces together in bunches on the same side), isolation isn't good but it's still more than fine for CMOS signals.
And as such, if your circuit has an impedance very different from the transmission line impedance, then every bit of trace length will matter.  A very high impedance circuit, like an oscilloscope front end, or a very low impedance circuit, like a high current switching power supply, will need much wider conductors and careful limits on trace length.
So a high impedance circuit might need greater clearance to (top) pour, thinner traces, and even no (bottom side) ground plane at all, for best results.  The downside is more crosstalk, so you need to work accordingly.

Approval(0) Reply

Submit
Share the Project